I have given the controversy of the Kelseyville team name and mascot a great deal of thought since the Board agreed to place the issue on the February agenda. After reading letters to the editor, related articles in the Record-Bee, and reviewing many websites on the issue, one thing that became obvious is the animosity that has been created in what formerly was the peaceful, friendly town of Kelseyville. And for what cause?
This began with one person demanding respect (for the Indians), and making appeals based on a tragedy that occurred in 1850. In an effort to be politically correct and “do the right thing” the Board reacted.
In changing the name from Indian ? a name that evokes courage, strength and spirit ? all qualities that convey respect, the very thing that was being demanded was taken away. While the Bloody Island Massacre was horrific, there are many atrocities that can be pointed to throughout our history where “white Europeans” could be called victims if they so chose. But one can choose to continually look back with self-pity, or look to the future and utilize the opportunities that this country has to offer each of us thus earning that sought after respect.
When met with opposition by the majority of local residents, the Board did agree to revisit their decision, but have been unable or are fearful to rescind their initial verdict. Do they need precedence? It”s there for them. On February 15, 2001, the Tomales High School Board voted to ban the name Braves. Facing then what the Kelseyville Board does today, Tomales had the courage to reinstate the mascot on March 22, 2001.
If the Board stays the course, what is next? Changing the name of the Pomo Elementary School in Clearlake, or all the rivers, lakes, cities, towns and 22 states that are named for Indian tribes or words? Obviously common sense needs to prevail. And to those who say this is unimportant, I reply that there is more than a name at stake here, beginning with infringement of the fundamental right of the majority to prevail.
Lynn Elder
Nyack, New York
